University Funding in Germany

In recent years German universities in all federal states have seen steep budget cuts. As a student myself, I was curious about how this manifests. My own university has the reputation of being chronically underfunded. How underfunded are German universities really? How are budget cuts politically justified and how do they look like?

University funding in Germany is the responsibility of the states, not of the federal government. Furthermore, unlike the federal government, states are not allowed to take up credit, as it is forbidden by the “Debt Break”, a constitutional law in Germany that aims at reducing the amount of debt government has. This, when coupled with very tight budgets, leads to states having to reduce investments into the future: Building bridges, maintaining roads, expanding public transportation - and of course education, which has the potential to add billions to the economy.

Budget Cuts

Some universities have seen cuts as steep as 10% year over year for their annual budgets. As a result, student coordinators are losing their jobs, young academics do not find jobs, important work is not being done.

Instead, we are seeing a trend towards funding universities through the use of funds. These funds have a limited runtime and can be dissolved without political cost when money is tight. They make budgeting in the education ministries much easier, but stop ANY form of planning security on the level of the university.

It also leads to non-sensical expenses. If the fund you have successfully applied to has excess cash which you do not need for your project, you are in no way disincentivised from using this money. Rather, you want to spend this money because otherwise it will not be accessible to you or your institution. The result is excess money for decorative benches, office decor and student jobs in writing newsletters noone is reading. On the other hand, student jobs that previously came from the more flexible university budget can no longer be financed and important work is not being done anymore.

EXPAND ON THIS, NAME CONCRETE EXAMPLES, TRY TO GET DATA FOR THE FUNDS THING

How underfunded are universities really?

For this, I have tried to unsuccessfully find a comprehensive list of the funding of all universities in Germany. I did notice that the “Federal Statistical Office of Germany”, or DESTATIS, did have comprehensive data on the funding of academic subfields. They also had datasets on the amount of students enrolled at individual universities.

One e-mail later, and I had a full table on the budgets of individual universities. Combining this with the already publicly available data on the DESTATIS website, we can not only find out which universities spend the most, but also how much they spend per student, a much more useful measurement.


The data is available here.


Results